DE

Free Market
Local Autonomy and Land Market Anomalies in South Sumatra

Padi Sonor, Land Rights, and Civic Space in South Sumatra's Wetlands
Horticulture
© Erwan Hesry on Unspalsh 

Everyone wants a healthy economic system, one that can drive investment quickly, produce commercial innovation, and bring prosperity to the regions. Inclusive economic progress, however, arises from a guarantee of security, and the most fundamental foundation of that prosperity is individual sovereignty over oneself and the protection of legitimate property rights. In managing common-pool resources such as wetlands and forests, long-term efficiency and a harmonious order are achieved when local communities are given full autonomy to set their own rules without unilateral intervention or coercion from outside. Yet the ideal of a fair market and independent management is often distorted when large-scale business permits are issued carelessly over lands managed by the people, without consent or voluntary agreement (Jurnal JIIS, Undiksha). In South Sumatra, this challenge is evident in widespread agrarian conflict, where unequal power relations not only strip residents of their property rights but also trample the most basic space for civil liberties.

One form of local sovereignty caught in the midst of this conflict is the tradition of Padi Sonor. For the wetland communities of South Sumatra, Sonor is not merely an ordinary farming technique. It is a tangible expression of traditional economic freedom and a concrete example of independently managing shared resources through local social institutions. In this practice, farmers use lebak (seasonal floodplain) or peat swamp land (Keberlangsungan Lahan Basah Gambut, Nadya Rahmania) communally, broadcasting seed when water levels recede sharply ahead of the long dry season. Without relying on subsidies, large outside capital, or centralized market regulation, this independent agrarian system has proven capable of sustaining local food security while adapting to the rhythms of nature for centuries.

Unfortunately, the space for independent economic activity and voluntary exchange within this local order has gradually narrowed due to the presence of state-sanctioned monopolistic rights. The entry of Timber Utilization Permits for Industrial Plantation Forests (IUPHHK-HTI) and Cultivation Rights (HGU) for large-scale palm oil plantations has drastically altered the hydrological landscape of the peatlands. Large canals have been built unilaterally to drain swamps, ultimately causing permanent damage to natural water ecosystems. Tragically, when land drainage triggers recurring risks of forest fires, state regulation takes the shortcut of banning all forms of land burning. Padi Sonor has been made a scapegoat without any fair substitute solution. As a result, rather than fostering a healthy and fair market competition for businesses of all scales, this intervention instead marginalizes the living space and independence of small communities.

The conflicts do not arise organically. Rather, they are supported by a systematic network from upstream to downstream. Upstream, concession permits and certificates are often issued over customary land (tanah ulayat) or inherited plots (lahan temurun) owned by residents, without an equal dialogue or voluntary consent from the original rights holders. When local communities try to defend their property rights, security apparatus downstream is frequently deployed as corporate backing, triggering repressive actions, physical intimidation, and even forced evictions using heavy machinery in the field.

The bleak picture of human rights enforcement is clearly reflected in the records of the National Human Rights Commission of Indonesia (Komnas HAM), which has received dozens of complaints of human rights violations in the Palembang area, dominated by land disputes and forced evictions. The real impact of this seizure of living space paralyzes residents' basic freedoms. Farmers lose sovereignty over their traditional lands because peat swamps are drained or rivers are dammed, until they become alienated and are forced to work as low-paid laborers on their own land. Farmers and environmental activists who vocally assert their property rights are, in turn, vulnerable to legal prosecution under criminal articles in order to secure projects. Children living in areas caught in HGU conflicts often face administrative obstacles related to civil registration that hinder their access to educational assistance. This local situation reflects the narrowing of civic space (civil space) in Indonesia, as also reflected in the Freedom in the World research by Freedom House, which confirms a declining trend in the protection of civil rights and restrictions on the rights to express oneself, assemble, and associate safely.

These conditions of agrarian conflict and the crisis of civil liberties were also a topic of lively discussion at the Civil Liberties and Human Rights Advocacy Training organized by the Lembaga INDEKS (Institut Demokrasi dan Kesejahteraan Sosial/Institute for Democracy and Social Welfare) together with FNF Indonesia in Palembang on 26–28 June 2026. Real cases, such as the threat to the Padi Sonor tradition and the criminalization of farmers defending their land, were among the main issues intensively discussed by local resource persons, namely Ipan Widodo (Director of LBH Palembang), as well as participants throughout the forum. In his presentation, Ipan stressed that law enforcement often appears biased: criminal instruments and security forces tend to be used as tools to silence and prosecute residents who fight for their land rights, while spatial planning violations and land grabbing by corporations escape legal action. Joined by expert resource persons such as Asfinawati (Lecturer at STHI Jentera) and Nanang Sunandar (Founder of INDEKS), participants not only mapped the problem of unequal power relations but also formulated concrete actions as solutions for long-term advocacy. The recommendations included collecting authentic evidence in the form of written testimony, photos, or videos related to rights violations and repression in the field, while also preparing young people as drivers of legal literacy for grassroots communities to sustain the continuity of the movement to protect people's property rights.

Through upholding the values of individual freedom and respect for human rights, the people of South Sumatra are expected to move together voluntarily to reclaim their seized living space and save agrarian traditions such as Padi Sonor. True prosperity has never been born from coercion or centralized regulation that strips citizens of their autonomy, but from a just legal order in which property rights are recognized and economic transactions can take place freely, without intimidation.

Atiyah Muthmainnah is Program Staff at Institut Demokrasi dan Kesejahteraan Sosial (INDEKS)